
It's 1999, and SNK is in dire straits. Coasting off the initial 1992 boom spurred on by Capcom's Street Fighter II: The World Warrior, they and others have rained a flood of fighting games onto an arcade market that was becoming increasingly unreceptive to them and more reliant upon non-game frivolities such as claw and medal games; a trend that, spoiler alert, does not reverse itself. Long story short: SNK needs to diversify, and they need to do it yesterday. Capcom on the other hand has nimbly kept pace with the gaming mainstream, having by this time two megahits on the PlayStation in the form of the subgenre-creating Resident Evil and its sequel. They're billed as "survival horror," but this perhaps obscures the fact that they're adventure games, through and through. The puzzles are vastly simplified compared to the point-and-click adventures that came previous, but this missing complexity is compensated for by an additional layer of tense resource management. A player navigates a geographical space and a story space just like any adventure game, but in their comings and goings they must constantly choose between running from the monsters they encounter, or expending scarce ammo to dispatch them.
Athena: Awakening from the Ordinary Life, released in 1999 in what would become an interesting footnote in old SNK's history, was described to my boyfriend as a survival horror game. Like much of what you hear on the internet, this is wrong. Athena is not survival horror, and has no aspirations of being any kind of RE knockoff; you control Athena herself through a fixed camera against prerendered backdrops in a "tank controls" scheme, but this is where the similarities end. Boku no Natsuyasumi is as much a survival horror game as Athena. Nonetheless, you can kind of see where SNK's head was at at this point in its existence. Anyway, you take control of the titular Athena, average Japanese high school girl et cetera, who discovers that she has a variety of psychic powers, and is thus swept up in a vast government conspiracy involving dinosaurs and science gone wrong. She isn't aware of the origin of these powers, nor the full extent of them, nor how much control she exactly has over them. Her friend Rika will witness these psychic abilities being used, in Athena's viewpoint for the sake of good, for the sake of helping save people, but nonetheless in a display of power that could be described as "cosmically frightening," which pushes her away. Also there's a clown. Indeed, Athena plants the seeds of a very interesting and complex story, but then something weird happens.
You see, Athena comprises three CDs; if you're at all familiar with the PSX in its heyday, you'll recall this being the same number of CDs Final Fantasy VII shipped on, a game that is dozens of hours long and encompasses a vast epic story. For the game that is our subject today, you will be swapping to disc 2 after about half an hour. Now, this is unusual, but not wholly unprecedented in the PSX library. My beloved Tokimeki Memorial 2 has a similarly abbreviated first disc for perfectly understandable technical reasons, after all. But to cut to the chase here, no, Athena has no justification for spanning three discs; it has plenty of FMV but it's rigidly linear, none of the in-game dialog is voiced, and a full playthrough is less than 10 hours in length. Without looking into the game's data, my best guess is that the video is bloated from inefficient compression. This in itself isn't really a knock against the game, like who really cares these days, but the game really wants you to "strap in" for something here, and you'd be forgiven for having something of a sinking feeling while so abruptly swapping to that second disc.
The kind of slow, non-action adventure game that Athena is thrives on story, yes, but also aesthetics. The prerendered environments evince somewhat of a "we're still figuring out this 3D modeling package" flair, much like the original Resident Evil, but they're tasteful and of their world, not clashing with the 3D character models, and appropriately mood setting. The music is wonderfully strange in almost all instances; when a new piece begins playing it's always the instrumentation that instantly takes you by surprise. Following that, you start bobbing your head. This stuff bangs. It's repetitive, but in the way that one section plays off of another section in perfect responsiveness, the kind of clever repetition that makes the music feel as though it's actually progressing, infinitely. In the calmer and less dancey pieces, there's a hypnotic, almost lulling quality to the music. Which is unfortunate, because it might actually put you to sleep.
Athena's developer Yumekobo, historically a purveyor of action and sports titles, seems utterly at a loss for what to do with an adventure game like this. In everything that you're tasked with, there is a striking lack of resistance. Come across a locked door, go ask someone how to unlock the door, they tell you to go to this place and/or talk to this person, they tell you where to get the key or passcode, you get the key or passcode, you unlock the door, repeat. Again and again this kind of chain of objectives occurs with precious little mechanical conflict, and effectively no additional story set dressing to contextualize in any interesting way the busywork you're doing. The psychic powers Athena is predicated upon feature only in select hotspots much too few and far between, and amount to quick time events at best. Worse, the couple of attempts at further mechanical robustness that are on offer are nigh indecipherable; semi-turn based scenes in which you're able to walk forward, walk backward, and perform one or two other scenario-specific actions, are presented with no explanation of what the player is supposed to be doing and when, and the feedback obtained from trying things out only serves to add confusion. Outside of these situations you'll sometimes be given a timed chain of objectives, but the time allotted is ample and merely impresses upon the player an all-too-easily broken illusion of urgency.
To be clear, it's not a lack of difficulty I criticize the game for here, it's a lack of engagement. The strict linearity by itself isn't a problem, provided there were a balancing element preventing the player from beelining each objective. The simplicity of the puzzles by itself isn't a problem, if there were larger environments and more small puzzles to juggle simultaneously. The lack of a persistent combative force by itself isn't a problem, with appropriately interesting story contextualization for what it is you are doing. No, it is, of course, all of these things together that are the cause of Athena's thorough mediocrity. I could even see a version of this game with more psychic QTEs peppered in being pretty decent, but that's not the game that was made. To be honest, I get the impression that this is far short of the game the developers wanted to make; so many aspects scream "time pressure." The numerous FMVs tucked betwixt and between all moments of gameplay deepen whatever you might be doing within the scenario of a given chapter, but little connective tissue is provided for whatever is going on in the interim. It's not unthinkable that you (Athena) may find yourself in a subway car right after the aquarium incident, sure, but going directly from the subway incident backward in time into a laboratory as a ghostly apparition is less readily explicable. It feels like there's huge chunks of facilitative story torn out here, only leaving the big moments. The FMVs themselves look quite good, but are marred by hideous and distracting visual tearing throughout. Any screen with more than 3 or so models brings the engine to its knees. This bite-sized game's mere existence across three whole discs indicates the developers either had a LOT more content planned or weren't able to efficiently compress all the data down to a reasonable size; either cause along with everything else suggests some serious corners were cut.
As it stands, Athena is a compilation of themed lists of chores pasting together some FMVs. In the absence of, say, any real choices to make, or a more expansive nonlinear world, or more involved game mechanics, or even just a more engaging story, there isn't a lot going on in it. It's around the time you've hit hour 3, already on the third disc, picking up your fifth plate of donuts off the floor to join the ones you've not had the occasion to eat because so little actually saps your health in the midst of another thoroughly tedious and tension-free fetch quest, that you finally stop wondering when the party is supposed to start.
Along with many other diverse money losing ventures including a handheld console that, while well loved, experienced a drubbing typical of those who go against the unstoppable worldwide handheld juggernaut of Nintendo and its Game Boy, and a theme park that by all accounts was a ruinous financial disaster, Athena: Awakening from the Ordinary Life too was not the smash blockbuster success SNK may have been hoping for, and they filed for bankruptcy the following year. It's a game that, while minor in the grand scheme of the company's collapse, nevertheless exemplifies SNK's desperate inability to adjust to changing tastes in the gaming market all too well, imitative of other far more successful games by companies they once considered peers and rivals, but only superficially so. It's not a cynical product, there is genuine creativity on display here, but by the time development began for SNK it was already too late, which resulted in too little.
2/5 (Bad)